Acting as your own general contractor in Westchester can save 10 to 20 percent on the contractor fee, but you take on the scheduling, the permits, and the liability for every trade. The savings often come with hidden costs: missed inspections, trade delays, and code upgrades you did not budget. It makes sense for a small, single trade job, not for a full home renovation.
How much can you save acting as your own general contractor in Westchester?
You can save 10 to 20 percent of the contractor fee by acting as your own general contractor in Westchester. The savings come from the markup a general contractor charges for scheduling, permits, and coordination. The tradeoff is that you take on all of that work and all of the liability.
The table below shows the savings and the tradeoff.
| Factor | With a general contractor | Acting as your own |
|---|---|---|
| Fee | 10 to 20 percent markup | Saved |
| Scheduling | Handled | You coordinate trades |
| Permits | Pulled and inspected | You pull and schedule |
| Liability | Contractor carries insurance | You carry the risk |
| Code upgrades | Budgeted up front | You find and pay for them |
I have homeowners ask me if they should act as their own general contractor to save the fee. For a single trade job, maybe. For a full home renovation, the savings disappear the first time a trade misses a week or an inspection fails. The fee I charge buys the schedule, the permit, and the insurance. That is what keeps a project from stalling.
— Julian Martelly, Licensed General Contractor, MHI Renovation Services
What do you take on when you act as your own general contractor?
When you act as your own general contractor in Westchester, you take on the scheduling of every trade, the permit applications, the inspections, the insurance, and the liability for any injury or damage. You also take on the code upgrades that the inspection requires, which you may not see coming. The work is real and the risk is real.
A general contractor is a coordinator and a risk holder. The fee pays for the schedule that keeps the trades moving and the insurance that covers the risk. Without a general contractor, both are yours.
- Schedule every trade in sequence
- Pull and schedule every permit and inspection
- Carry liability insurance for the project
- Handle code upgrades the inspection requires
- Coordinate material deliveries and site access
When does acting as your own general contractor make sense?
Acting as your own general contractor makes sense for a small, single trade job where you know the trade, like a paint job or a flooring install you can supervise. It does not make sense for a full home renovation with plumbing, electrical, and structural work, where the coordination and the liability are too high for a homeowner to carry.
The size of the job and the number of trades decide it. One trade you can supervise is manageable. Five trades that need to sequence, with permits and inspections, is a full time job. We are honest about which is which.
What are the hidden costs of acting as your own general contractor?
The hidden costs of acting as your own general contractor are trade delays, missed inspections, code upgrades you did not budget, and the time you spend on the project instead of your work. A trade that misses a week stalls the whole project. A failed inspection means a rework. These costs often exceed the fee you saved.
The fee a general contractor charges is not just profit. It is the cost of a schedule that does not stall and an inspection that passes the first time. A homeowner who coordinates for the first time pays the learning cost in delays and rework.
Who carries the insurance when you act as your own general contractor?
When you act as your own general contractor, you carry the liability insurance for the project, and you must confirm every trade carries their own workers compensation. If a trade is uninsured and a worker is injured on your property, your homeowner policy may not cover the claim. A general contractor carries the insurance that protects you.
The insurance is the biggest hidden risk. A general contractor's liability policy covers the project. A homeowner's policy may not cover a trade injury, especially if the trade is unlicensed or uninsured. We carry the insurance so you do not carry the risk.
How do you decide whether to hire a general contractor in Westchester?
Call (914) 656-0885 or request a free quote. We assess the scope, tell you honestly whether it needs a general contractor or whether a single trade will do, and hand you an itemized quote. You decide with the real numbers, not a guess.
We do not push a general contractor on a job that does not need one. We also do not let a homeowner take on a full renovation without knowing the risk. A site visit gives you an honest recommendation and a quote you can compare.
Frequently Asked Questions
The fee a general contractor charges buys a schedule that moves and an inspection that passes. Acting as your own can save the fee, but it takes on the risk and the time. If you want to weigh the real numbers, call (914) 656-0885 or request a free quote today.
MHI Renovation Services Inc. · Yonkers, NY · (914) 656-0885
